Leader of the Pack
23 January 2012
It’s been well-established that our pit bull, Roxie, is adorable and we love her. After all, who could not love this face?
Adora-bull
But as with any shelter dog, Roxie came with some baggage. Roxie’s most serious issue became apparent on the first day we had her, when we left her shut in our guest room for five minutes and she responded by howling her head off and scratching away the paint on the door frame. Roxie hated to be left alone or confined in any way – I guess I would, too, if I’d been shut up in a shelter kennel for almost six months.
Initially, we put her crate in our bedroom, but soon that arrangement began to have a detrimental effect on, you know, our relationship. So we moved the crate out to our library/dining room. We had to drag the guest bedroom mattress in there and sleep on the floor for the first few nights to get her to settle down even slightly. Eventually, she would go to sleep on her own, but she still woke us up several times a night with intermittent whines and barks.
During the day, if I stepped out of my office to so much as get a drink of water, her high-pitched cries followed me about 15 seconds later. And if we left the apartment (which we did with increasing rarity), she would immediately whine and howl, with mounting fervor, and/or bark continuously until we returned. Luckily, we have very understanding neighbors, most of whom are dog owners themselves. But for the sake of our sanity and theirs, we knew this couldn’t go on forever.
I admit, there were some times, especially in the first few days, when I had serious thoughts about returning her to the shelter. I knew dogs were more work than cats, but I wasn’t prepared for this. I was constantly on edge and felt trapped in our apartment.
At first, we thought the issue was separation anxiety, but after doing some more research, we realized it was actually more akin to isolation distress, which is less severe but still extremely annoying. Basically, separation anxiety is a sort of panic attack; if left alone, dogs with separation anxiety will salivate, shake all over, and do just about anything to escape, including harming themselves and whatever unfortunate inanimate objects might stand in their way. Isolation distress is more like a doggy tantrum. Roxie wanted us around all the time, and she was letting us know, ear-splittingly loud and clear.
One day, after well over a month of trying and failing to get Roxie to calm down, I was trawling the archives of one of my favorite pit bull blogs, Two Pitties in the City (written by a Chicago couple who have two pits and also founded a dog walking club called SociaBulls – more on that later), and I came across a post about how their dog, Mr. B, overcame his isolation distress after just one session with a local dog trainer named Curtis Scott. I immediately found his website and sent him an email describing our problems with Roxie, and he agreed to come to our apartment to evaluate her a few days later. I was afraid to get my hopes up too high, but as it turned out, all those glowing, 5-star Yelp reviews don’t lie: Curtis Scott is a total badass. He has 8 pitties himself, and he knows how to handle powerful dogs. Curtis was here for an hour, and in that time Roxie went from a barking, whining bundle of nerves, to sitting calmly in her crate, in a submissive, relaxed posture.
We learned a lot from Curtis, but perhaps the most important thing he taught us is that it’s not just the tone of voice that matters when you give verbal commands to your dog, it’s the pitch. We were responding to Roxie’s high-pitched whines with high-pitched scolding, which just served to create more excitement. Dropping our voices to a lower, almost growly tone showed her that we meant business, and he advised us to give her a strong correction at the first sign of vocalization, rather than letting her ramp up to full-on tantrum mode. Curtis also demonstrated how to make the “mean dog face” – another way to communicate to Roxie that we’re the “alpha dogs” of the household.
Nate demonstrates the “mean dog face” – Roxie is, as you can see, utterly terrified.
All of this pretty much blew Roxie’s mind – I don’t think she’d ever had a human really take charge with her before. We’re fairly sure her original owners got her as a puppy and didn’t discipline her in the slightest (probably why they couldn’t handle her as an full-grown dog and foisted her off on the Anti-Cruelty Society). Now, I don’t think these techniques would go over so well with a timid or fearful dog. But Roxie is strong-willed and stubborn (kinda like her mama…), and she needs a firmer, more dominant presence to keep her in line. The point of this type of discipline is not to intimidate or scare your dog, but to make them realize that you’re in charge, so they don’t have to be.
Roxie still isn’t fond of being left in her crate, but she’s made considerable progress. We have a “ritual” that we follow when leaving her home alone that seems to do the trick: first, we put in her the crate very calmly, at least 10 minutes before we need to leave, then completely ignore her (except to correct any whining with the “quiet” command) until we’re ready to go. We leave a radio playing next to her crate to block out any ambient noise from the street or the other units. When we exit the apartment, we do it as quietly and calmly as possible, without rushing. Then we wait outside the door. At the first sign of whining, we open the door and tell her “quiet” in a growly alpha-dog voice (seriously, our neighbors must think we’re such freaks). If her whining escalates to howling or barking, we barge back in with a much louder “quiet!” and sometimes even a rap on the side of her crate, then turn and leave again. When we first started doing this, it would take about 20 minutes to get her to settle down. Now, we might get one or two little whimpers, and then she falls silent and remains that way until we return. We can go to the store, go out to eat, go see a movie – it’s almost like I have a life again!
The next big project with Roxie is getting her to stop pulling on the leash. Roxie is reasonably well-behaved on walks, but sometimes prey drive or good old-fashioned curiosity takes over, sending her barreling off towards yummy-looking squirrels or the fun-smelling shopping bags of strangers. And with all my physical problems, one ill-timed lunge is all it takes to pull my back completely out of whack and doom me to yet another $65 chiropractor visit.
I can haz delicious squirrels?
Our solution so far has been for Nate to do most of the dog walking (he was once a professional, after all) and for me to use a shock-absorbing bungee leash when I do have to take her out (we have the Cujo Leash from Ezydog, and also their Chest Plate Harness). In the interest of helping Roxie improve her leash manners, we’ve joined the aforementioned SociaBulls walking club, which meets every Sunday morning for a “pack walk” somewhere in Chicago. The dogs (not all pit bulls, by the way, though there are quite a few) aren’t allowed to physically interact with one another, which teaches them to socialize respectfully and keep their energy under control. Roxie has been on two SociaBulls walks so far, and we can already see a difference in her on-leash behavior. It’s also been great to meet all the responsible, knowledgeable – and friendly! – dog owners who are part of the group. Roxie is a work in progress (aren’t we all?), but with such a supportive community to rely on, I feel much more equipped to handle whatever future adventures in pet parenting we may encounter.


























